2001 CLGA Annual General Meeting

May 7, 2001

President's Report

I would like to take a moment to summarize some of the Board's activities before I was elected President in June, 2000. And I hope you will forgive me for its brevity as I was not a member of the Board nor did I attend meetings before June 6th.

The Board's membership at the Annual General Meeting, May 8, 2000 was: Edward Tompkins, President; Heather Ramsey, Vice-President; Pat Reed, Secretary and Paul Li, Treasurer. Other members were Alan Miller, Dave Smith, Patricia Swerhone and Randi Williams.

Much of the Board's attention was focused on the following areas:

  1. The National Portrait Collection.
  2. Archival Exhibits in Xtra's reception area;
  3. Negotiations with members of faculty at University College, the University of Toronto. These negotiations opened a dialogue between the Board and the University to explore the possibility of moving the Archives to the University campus; and
  4. Our Human Rights case: Scott Brockie and Imaging Excellence, Incorporated vs. Ray Brillinger, Past-President of CLGA, the CLGA and the Ontario Human Rights Commission. The Ontario Human Rights Commission found that Scott Brockie and Imaging Excellence Incorporated did discriminate against Ray Brillinger and the CLGA by refusing to print stationery and envelopes for the Archives. Mr. Brockie was fined $5,000; however he is appealing the decision by the Commission. I will speak more about this later.

Edward Tompkins resigned from the Board on June 6, 2000. I would like to commend Edward for his work, his vision, his scholarship, his dedication and his love for the Archive. One of his most important achievements is the National Portrait Collection. This is an important addition to our Archives honoring lesbians and gays across Canada. Also, it has drawn our attention to artists who have given their artistry and craftsmanship to build this into a collection of high artistic merit.

Edward, in his quiet way, has tried to carve out something very Canadian. The first collection, 25 Lives, is a first statement on lesbian and gay liberation politics that is uniquely Canadian while drawing from both the American and European cultures to show us that we are different and we are leaders. Combined with the show in 2000 on Tolerance, it points to the many different ways lesbians and gays are filling in critical areas of our leadership in politics, religion and literature, native Canadian and Asian-Canadian cultures. Underlying these collections is a vision of individual and collective achievement of discovery and fulfillment. In pointing to our unfolding past, it shows us, as individual gays and lesbians, a vision of our power, our diversity and our complexity. This is exactly what our Archives should do. It should show us our histories and give support for research and leadership in the future.

Also, the Board had to bid goodbye and thanks to Edward's partner and life companion. Chris Bondy has worked as the Archives' lawyer on our Human Rights Case. He has done this pro bono, which means for free!! He has given us his skill, time, energy, dedication and knowledge. With Chris, we won Round One!

On June 6, 2000, I was elected President effectively July 1, 2000. Much of my time in the summer was spent in changing over administrations and meeting with volunteers involved in the Archives. Since July, it has been a very busy time and a very challenging one. Here are a few of the highlights and challenges that the Archives faced last year:

First a few challenges! Patricia Swerhone and Pat Reid resigned before I held my first meeting with the Board. At my first meeting, Paul Li asked to be replaced. It was with deep regret that I accepted Pat Reid's resignation as she was one of the most responsible members in lending advice and acting as Secretary. The Board wishes her well and hopes she will return to us as a volunteer sometime in the future. Paul Li has been a treasure of a Treasurer! He worked diligently keeping our finances and records in perfect order. He continued to meet with the Board for several months after his resignation to make sure that our financial house was in order.

The Board's membership in 2000 was: Matt Hughes, President; Heather Ramsay, Vice-President; Alan Miller, Secretary; David DeBois, Treasurer; with Elise Chenier, Caitlin Ryan, Dave Smith, and Randi Williams. Edward Tompkins is Past President and I have created the advisory position of Past-Past President Ray Brillinger to help and advise me in Edward's absence.

The files and administrative matters in respect to representation of the Archives and Ray Brillinger in the Human Rights Complaint against Scott Brockie and Imaging Excellence, Inc., has been transferred from Chris Bondy to David L. Corbett of Eberts Symes Street & Corbett, Barristers and Solicitors. At the moment Karen Spector, who recently joined Eberts Symes Street & Corbett, has been assigned our case. The appeal was perfected on April 23, 2001. Brockie's lawyer also served an amended notice of motion challenging the constitutionality of the Human Rights Code itself on the basis that the Code does not provide for a bona fided defense to a finding of discrimination under section 1. Consequently, Brockie's lawyer is requesting an order declaring the Code to be unconstitutional and staying the order of the Board of Inquiry to permit the Code to be amended. Since Brockie is challenging the constitutionality of the Code, the Court is required to serve a Notice of Constitutional Question on the Attorney General of Canada and the Attorney General of Ontario to permit them to intervene in this appeal if they so choose. This required notice was served on April 30, 2001. Ms Spector is preparing responding materials.

A Newsletter Committee was established with Elio Iannacci acting as Editor. With numerous delays, no newsletters were printed. Mr. Iannacci was replaced with Brad Walton in the new year.

In August, our storage unit on John Street received water damage, mainly to works of minor fiction. The Board is proceeding to Ontario Small Claims Court to recover some of the $3,000 in damages for alleged negligence on the part of the owner. Mr. Robert Coates has given us pro bono legal advice in the matter.

In September, to add insult to injury, the Archives main facility on Temperance Street received water damage from a leaking water tank on the third floor. Approximately, $2,000 in damage occurred, mostly to archival quality boxes. Quick action on the part of volunteers saved the Archives further damage. It appears that the Archives will have to absorb the cost of this water damage as our lease states quite clearly that we must have insurance for internal damages. Our policy had a $10,000 waiver of liability. This has been renegotiated to $500.

A National Portrait Committee was approved with Dave Smith as Chair. This step moved a important item to a Committee freeing more Board time for other business.

I have chosen two key areas as part of my administration. They are Visibility of the Archives and, more importantly, Fund Raising:

(1) With regard to visibility, the Board is in final negotiations with Rexall Drugs to put a semi-permanent display case in the unused doorway of Novack's Pharmacy at the Church/Wellesley intersection. Artistic designs by Bruce Jones have been approved by the Board, Novack's manager, May Wong and Rexall Drugs senior management. Final approval of the plans is pending.

I have approached the President of Pink Triangle Press, Ken Poppert, to provide ongoing space in Xtra in their several publications in Toronto and across Canada to help raise our profile and highlight some of our activities. We have reached a preliminary agreement.

Mark Thompson, a professional PR agent currently working for CBC, has agreed to do our PR work as a volunteer.

The Archives was featured in the advertising for the Ottawa-Hull Mr. Leather Contest and the Archives manned a table at Xtra's Gay and Lesbian Life Style Show in Toronto.

The Archives sponsored a lecture by Dave Smith on A History of Erotic Male Photography in the Bank Hall of the Heritage Building. This hugely popular lecture added names to our mailing list while attracting attention to the Archives by using slides, books and pamphlets from our collection.

(2) With regard to Fund Raising, my approach has been to rely on past fund raising experiences. The approach to the Board was simple, based on the three G's of the New York Metropolitan Opera Company: Give, Get or Get Off. I would like to thank members of the Board in aiding me as their new President in accepting change for the good of the Archives. I would like to thank Heather Ramsay who is stepping down as Vice-President but remaining as a member of the Board. Her advice and sense of humour has been invaluable. Also, I would like to thank David DuBoise, our Treasurer, who is leaving the Board. He has given his time and skill in managing our financial security. In addition, the Board and members of the Operation Committee attended a workshop based on a new fund raising strategy build around the mandate and values of the organization. This is still a work in progress in shaping our mandate and identifying the inherent values of the Archives.

A fund raising appeal in the form of a letter was sent out in November. The letter was a success in raising additional money for the operation of the Archives. Other activities include establishing connections on-line with the charitable fund raising groups Millenium Art Gallery in Vancouver and Charity.ca in Toronto.

A National Advisory Council has been created with its first two members: Jane Rule, noted lesbian author living in British Columbia and Stuart Hamilton, C.M., gay operatic coach to some of the finest singer in the world and Canada's Opera Quiz Host on CBC's Saturday Afternoon at the Opera. The Board hopes to add more names in time. The purpose of the National Advisory Council is a fund raising tool. No one on the Council will be involved in policy decisions.

Volunteers at the Archives checked coats at the Christmas Dinner and Dance for Prime Timers.

I met with representatives of the three levels of government in Toronto to discuss ways our representatives could help the Archives. Bill Graham, our MP, has agreed that his Secretary would help guide us through the application procedures for Federal Grants and he would share with us some information on his own sources of political funds. George Smitherman, our MPP, appears better to help us after the next election; although the Board is looking at making another application for a Trillium grant. George feels he can be of help in this respect. Kyle Rae, our guardian angel at City Hall, has given us his experience, assistance and a cheque.

With regard to fund raising, I would like to make one thing clear. The responsibility for the financial security and fund raising for the Archives is the responsibility of everyone. I can not do this alone and the Board can not do it without a great deal more help from the community than we are receiving. With all volunteer organizations, mandate aside, a great deal of time by volunteers is given to raise money for the well being of the organization. The Archives needs your help. We need the help of more volunteers to write letters, stuff envelopes and to build contacts. The Archives needs help in writing thank-you letters and making phone calls. This is not rocket science and does not require special skills; but, it is the type of work that is invaluable to any fund raising.

Another area of growing concern for the Archives is the lack of space in our Temperance Street location. The Operation Committee has been trying to determine ways to save space. In addition, meetings have been held with Dr. David Rayside, Acting Principal of University College, the University of Toronto, to continue discussions began by Edward Tompkins concerning moving the Archives to the campus of University College. Discussions are preliminary, on-going and no decisions have been reached by either the University or the Board. The Board is considering two other alternatives: renting a larger space or buying a facility suitable for the Archives. No decision has been made here either. No decision can be made until the annual budget of the Archives is secure.

Finally, the Archives is alive. It is healthy and it is a national treasure. Aside from fund raising for AIDS, there is no other gay or lesbian organization more important than the Archives. Gays and lesbians without a history are nothing. We are the preservers of our community's histories and this gift is one of the most important for us in Canada as no other public institutions are doing the job as well as we do it. No small amount of credit is due to the enormous effort on the part of our volunteers. In particular, I would like to thank present and past members of the Board for serving the Archives. In addition, no small measure of the success of the Archives is more deserving than members of the Operations Committee: Alan Miller (my left arm who offers advice on archival matters and who is always on the lookout for a pretty face), Don McLeod, Lawrence Bennett (my right arm who is on and off his sabbatical depending on what crisis is looming who is always willing to convert the unconverted into a volunteer, particularly if he has a pretty face!), David Kilgore, Harold Averill (my personal Mr. Archives), Paul Leatherdale, Paul Shearer (who has proven to be invaluable in fund raising) and Gerry King (our volunteer of the year, perhaps decade). Also, my life was made easier by the helpfulness, professionalism and smiling faces of Mario Ciancibello, our man in computers, Bruce Jones, whose artistic talent presents our image to the public, and Tom Horn, our banking and fund raising records whiz. To all other volunteers, I give you my thanks for your efforts in organizing, cataloguing and finding material for our collection making the Archives the invaluable resource it is to Canada.

Lastly, but not least, I would like to thank and acknowledge the work that my partner, Roger Johnson, has given to the Archives in the form of answering countless phone calls, taking messages, making appetizers, making and serving wine and cooking dinner for business and social occasions for the Archives.

Respectfully submitted,

Matt Hughes
President
May 7, 2001


Minutes from the Annual General Meeting, May 7, 2001

Canadian Lesbian & Gay Archives (C.L.G.A.)
(519 Church Street Community Centre, Toronto)

Present: The following members of the Board were present: Matt Hughes (President), Heather Ramsay (Vice-President), Elise Chenier, Caitlin Ryan, Dave Smith & Randi Williams

Absent: The following members of the Board were unable to attend:
Alan Miller (Secretary) and David Dubois (Treasurer)

The meeting convened at 6:30pm with 20 people in attendance. The President requested that in Alan Miller's absence Dave Smith be responsible for taking the minutes of the meeting.

  1. Review of the Minutes of A.G.M. May 8, 2000: There being no errors or omissions a motion to accept the minutes was moved by Jerry King, seconded by Harold Averill and carried.
  2. Financial Report for the Fiscal Year ending December 31, 2000: The auditor was unable to prepare the audited financial statement in time for the meeting so the President suggested that he and Paul Li present an interim report pending completion of the audit. There have been a substantial change in our financial position. Due to some changes in the allocation of funds, there will be a small deficit ($4,000.00) for this fiscal year. In future it was suggested that both the audited financial statement and a budget for the new fiscal year be presented at the A.G.M. A motion to accept the financial report as presented was made by Heather Ramsay, seconded by Don MacLeod and carried.
  3. Appointment of Arthur Gelgoot & Associates as Auditors for the fiscal year 2001-2002: A motion to appoint Arthur Gelgoot as the C.L.G.A.'s auditors for the 2001-2002 fiscal year was moved by Cliff Collier, seconded by Randi Williams and carried.
  4. The President's Report: Matt Hughes delivered his report. A copy is attached.
  5. The Operations Committee Report: Jerry King delivered the report for Alan Miller. A copy is attached.
  6. The National Portrait Committee: Dave Smith delivered the report. It was pointed out that this was a year of reorganization for the Committee and an opportunity to formalize the nomination procedures. With the adoption of the selection criteria and the nomination form, the process is now more accessible to the public. In recognizing the limited resources of the C.L.G.A. and volunteer time, the Committee reduced the number of inductees. This year, there will be four. The work continues as the Committee works towards a September induction reception and a possible display at Queen's Park.
  7. Accent on Youth Committee: Randi Williams delivered the report. The main work of the Committee will be to increase the C.L.G.A. visibility amongst youth groups. In so doing the Committee will work closely with others within the C.L.G.A. most especially the Accent on Minorities Committee.
  8. Accent on Minorities Committee: Heather Ramsay delivered the report. The Committee has not yet had a chance to meet but they will work closely with other members of the C.L.G.A. to help promote visibility of minority groups.
  9. Acceptance of the President's Report and the Committee Reports: Matt Hughes moved that the President's Report and the Committee Reports be accepted which was seconded by Jerry King and carried.
  10. Other Business:
    1. Elise Chenier noted the joint presentation she'll be giving on June 19th and invited all to attend
    2. Dave Smith noted the presentation he'll be giving on May 16th and invited all to attend.
    3. Alan Rayside requested an opportunity to make a presentation to the Board and was invited to do so at a future date.
    4. The C.L.G.A.'s participation in the upcoming Pride Day was briefly discussed and some suggestions made for consideration by the Board.
  11. Nomination and Election of the Board of Directors: Heather Ramsay read the list of names nominated for Board membership and asked if there were any further nominations. There were none. As the nominations did not exceed the number of positions, voting by ballot was not necessary. Cliff Collier moved that those nominated be elected, which was seconded by Patricia Swerhone and carried.
  12. Adjournment: The President thanked all those who attended the A.G.M. and thanked them for their valuable input to the meeting. Then he made a motion to adjourn which was seconded by Randi Williams and carried. The meeting ended at 8:00PM.

Report of the Board Meeting

May 7, 2001
Election of Officers

Elise Chenier moved that the Board officers for 2001 - 2002 should be:

  1. Matt Hughes, President;
  2. Dave Smith, Vice-President;
  3. Alan Miller, Secretary;
  4. Caitlin Ryan, Treasurer.

The motion was seconded by Randi Williams and carried.